In a fascinating thread about designing a typeface in Illustrator versus a font editor, renowned typographer Jonathan Hoefler lets us peek behind the curtains.
But moreover, the reason not to design typefaces in a drawing program is that there, you’re drawing letters in isolation, without regard to their neighbors. Here’s the lowercase G from first corner of the HTF Didot family, its 96pt Light Roman master, which I drew toward the end of 1991. (Be gentle; I was 21.) I remember being delighted by the results, no doubt focussing on that delicate ear, etc. But really, this is only half the picture, because it’s impossible to know if this letter works, unless you give it context. Here it is between lowercase Ns, which establish a typographic ‘control’ for an alphabet’s weight, width, proportions, contrast, fit, and rhythm. Is this still a good G? Should the upper bowl maybe move left a little? How do we feel about its weight, compared to its neighbors? Is the ear too dainty?